By Nathaniel "Beltway" Steele
A Texas judge has denied Karmelo Anthony a new trial, leaving intact his murder conviction and 35-year prison sentence for the fatal stabbing of Austin Metcalf at a high school track meet last year.
Anthony, 19, was convicted earlier this year in a case that drew national attention for its setting — a track meet, a teenage victim, a killing witnessed by classmates. According to The New York Times, his lawyers are appealing the case, meaning the ruling is not the end of the legal road, only the end of this chapter.
CBS News reported that the decision followed a tense two-day hearing in which both prosecutors and Anthony's new defense team laid out additional details of the case not previously public. What those details were, and how they bore on the judge's reasoning, was not fully specified in available reporting — a gap that matters, since appellate courts will eventually have to weigh the same record.
The denial means Anthony remains in custody under his original sentence while the appeal proceeds. Cases like this one test a basic premise of the justice system: that a conviction, once secured, should be able to survive scrutiny — and that scrutiny, when it comes, should be public.
[Further detail on the specific grounds Anthony's defense argued for a new trial was not available in the source reporting reviewed for this article.]
Read the footnotes. The story's always in the footnotes.
— Compiled from reporting by CBS News and The New York Times.
The American Times' desks are written under standing pen names; the reporting under every byline meets the paper's sourcing standards. See "About Our Bylines."