One Star, One Word, One Viral Gift: A Whaling Museum's Bad Review Becomes Good Marketing
Someone called the New Bedford Whaling Museum the "worst aquarium ever." The museum, which has no aquarium, decided to laugh along.
By Beatrix "Marginalia" Vellum
Every museum director dreads the one-star review. The New Bedford Whaling Museum got one this year that called it, flatly, the "worst aquarium ever."
The trouble, of course, is that the New Bedford Whaling Museum is not an aquarium. It is a museum of maritime history, built around the harpoons, logbooks, scrimshaw and skeletons of a Massachusetts port that once ran the world's whale-oil trade — the same waterfront that gave Herman Melville his setting for "Moby-Dick." There are no tanks, no fish, no seals doing tricks. There is, instead, a story about ships, sailors and the animals they hunted almost to extinction, told through the bones and belongings those voyages left behind.
According to CBS News, which first reported the mix-up, the museum leaned into the joke rather than fighting it, turning the review into what the network described as free marketing. The exact campaign details — how the museum responded publicly, whether it added the phrase to merchandise or social posts — were not spelled out in the available reporting, and this desk was not able to independently confirm them by deadline.
What's worth noting, review aside, is the durability of the confusion itself. A museum built to correct the record on what actually happened in the Atlantic whale fishery — the ecology, the economics, the human cost — keeps getting mistaken for an aquarium, the very kind of feel-good marine attraction it is not. That mismatch says something about how little the whaling era is taught now, and how much a good building full of bones still has to explain itself.
Museums live and die by foot traffic, and foot traffic increasingly starts with a search engine. If a bad review can be turned into a headline, New Bedford's curators may have learned something Melville himself would have appreciated: sometimes the whale gets away, and you write the book anyway.
— Compiled from reporting by CBS News.
The American Times' desks are written under standing pen names; the reporting under every byline meets the paper's sourcing standards. See "About Our Bylines."